Physical Gold Investments vs Online Gold ETFs

Compare physical gold investments and online gold ETFs. Gain insights into the benefits and drawbacks of each investment approach.

What are Online Gold ETFs?

Online Gold ETFs, or Exchange-Traded Funds, are investment funds that provide investors with the opportunity to gain exposure to gold without the need to physically own the metal. Here’s a detailed breakdown of their characteristics and how they function:

How Gold ETFs Operate

• Exchange-Traded: Gold ETFs are traded on stock exchanges similar to stocks, allowing for easy buying and selling throughout the trading day.
  
  
• Gold-Backed Assets: These funds invest in gold-backed assets, which may include physical gold, gold derivatives, or stocks of gold mining companies.
  
  
• Management: Most Gold ETFs are passively managed, aiming to track the performance of gold prices closely.
  
  

Types of Gold ETFs

• Physical Gold ETFs: These ETFs invest directly in physical gold, storing bullion in secured vaults. They aim to mirror the movements of gold spot market prices.
  
• Gold Mining ETFs: These funds invest in a diversified portfolio of gold mining companies, providing exposure to the gold production sector.
  
• Commodity ETFs: Focus on tracking gold prices through financial instruments or physical ownership, depending on the fund’s structure.
  
  

What is Physical Gold Investment?

Physical gold investment involves acquiring and holding gold in tangible forms such as bullion, coins, or jewelry. This section explores the various aspects and considerations of investing in physical gold.

Forms of Physical Gold

• Bullion and Bars: Gold bullion is primarily investment-grade gold in the form of bars or ingots, characterized by a purity of at least 99.5%. Each piece typically has the manufacturer’s details, weight, and purity stamped on it.
  
  
• Coins: These vary in design and often carry a premium due to their collectible nature and artistic elements. Unlike bullion, coins may have additional value based on rarity and design.
  
  
• Jewelry: Making up about 43% of the gold market, jewelry is not only an adornment but also a form of investment. However, it tends to have higher markups due to craftsmanship.
  
  

Key Considerations

• Purity and Weight: The value of physical gold items is determined by their purity, often measured in karats, with 24 karats signifying pure gold, and their weight, usually noted in troy ounces.
  
  
• Purchasing and Authenticity: Physical gold can be bought from reputable sources such as government and private mints, jewelers, and specialized dealers. It’s crucial to verify the authenticity and quality of gold to avoid counterfeits.
  
  
• Storage and Security: Owning physical gold requires secure storage solutions, which might involve safes or deposit boxes, adding to the investment’s overall cost.
  
  
• Liquidity and Market Value: While gold is a globally recognized asset, its liquidity can vary. Selling physical gold may not be as swift as selling gold ETFs, especially in larger quantities. The selling price may also include deductions over the spot price, depending on the form of gold (bars, coins, or jewelry).
  
  

Advantages of Gold ETFs

• Cost-Effectiveness and Convenience: Gold ETFs provide a more affordable entry point for investors compared to physical gold. They eliminate the need for storage, transportation, and insurance, which are necessary and often costly aspects of owning physical gold.
  
  
  This makes Gold ETFs particularly attractive for smaller investments. Additionally, they do not incur making charges, adding to their cost-effectiveness.
  
  
• Liquidity and Flexibility: Gold ETFs are highly liquid investments, traded on major stock exchanges just like stocks. This allows investors to buy and sell their holdings easily throughout the trading day, providing flexibility and the ability to react quickly to market changes.
  
  The ability to trade ETFs digitally enhances this flexibility, offering investors the convenience of managing their investments from anywhere.
  
  
• Diversification and Security: Investing in Gold ETFs allows investors to diversify their portfolios without the need to physically hold the gold. This not only reduces the risk associated with physical storage but also provides exposure to different assets within the gold sector.
  
  Gold ETFs are considered safe as they are backed by actual gold bullion, providing a secure investment option. They also offer potential tax benefits, which can enhance the overall return on investment.
  
  

Disadvantages of Gold ETFs

• Tax Implications: Gold ETFs are often taxed at higher capital gains rates, similar to other commodities, with the top rate for long-term investments being 28%. This can make Gold ETFs less attractive compared to other investment vehicles with lower tax rates.
  
  
• Management and Expense Ratios: Gold ETFs typically carry management fees and expense ratios that can significantly affect overall returns. These fees are generally higher than those for funds that track large indices like the S&P 500. Additionally, there are annual fees covering management and administration costs, adding to the ongoing expense of holding these ETFs.
  
  
• Market and Counterparty Risks: Leveraged Gold ETFs are designed to amplify the returns of gold price movements, but this feature also means they can magnify losses, posing a significant risk, especially to novice investors. In addition to leverage risks, Gold ETFs may encounter performance issues during periods of economic uncertainty or geopolitical instability.
  
  Unlike physical gold, which is often seen as a safer investment haven, Gold ETFs might not offer the same level of security and reliability in such times. Furthermore, investing in Gold ETFs introduces counterparty risks, which arise because the investment’s success depends on the management and financial health of another entity responsible for the security, insurance, and accurate gold price tracking. This type of risk is not a concern with physical gold investments, where the investor has direct ownership of the gold, eliminating the reliance on another party’s performance.
  
  Lastly, Gold ETFs are susceptible to tracking errors, meaning there’s a possibility they won’t precisely reflect the price movements of gold. These errors can occur due to minor inaccuracies in tracking or if the fund fails to fully represent gold’s price dynamics, further complicating the investment landscape for those interested in gold exposure through ETFs.
  
  
• No Direct Ownership: Investors in Gold ETFs do not own the gold physically; they hold shares in a fund that tracks the price of gold, which can lead to discrepancies between the perceived and real value of the investment.
  
  

Advantages of Physical Gold

Economic and Geopolitical Advantages

• Security and Direct Ownership: Investing in physical gold offers a high level of security as it eliminates counterparty risk, meaning there is no reliance on another party’s ability to fulfill a contract or maintain the value of the investment. Investors hold direct ownership of their gold, providing a tangible asset that can be held and managed without the need for intermediaries.
  

• Hedge Against Inflation: Gold is renowned for its ability to retain value and even appreciate during periods of high inflation. Its price often rises in response to events that cause the value of paper investments, like stocks and bonds, to decline.
  
  
• Safe Haven: In times of geopolitical and macroeconomic uncertainty, gold historically gains a higher appeal, as it is considered a safer asset that can help preserve wealth.
  
  
• Universal Value: Gold is recognized globally for its intrinsic value, which is not tied to any particular government or financial system, making it a robust store of value across different economic conditions.
  
  

Practical Advantages

• Liquidity: Physical gold maintains a consistently high level of liquidity. It can be sold or exchanged for cash or goods and services relatively easily, with significant trading volumes ensuring that gold can be liquidated quickly if needed.
  
  
• Appreciation Potential: Over the past decades, the price of gold has shown substantial appreciation, offering potential for capital gains in addition to its role as a stable investment.
  
  
• Diversification: By adding gold to an investment portfolio, investors can achieve a lower overall risk level due to gold’s low correlation with other asset classes. This diversification can stabilize investment returns during market volatility.
  
  

Disadvantages of Physical Gold

• Storage and Security Concerns: Physical gold requires secure storage solutions, which can be a significant disadvantage for many investors. Storing gold at home may pose security risks, while using bank lockers incurs additional costs. This need for secure storage and the associated expenses can add considerably to the overall investment burden.
  
  
• Ongoing Costs: Besides the initial purchase, physical gold ownership involves ongoing costs such as insurance and safekeeping. These costs can diminish the net returns from gold investments, making them less attractive compared to other assets that might offer dividends or interest.
  
  
• No Passive Income: Unlike stocks or bonds, physical gold does not generate any income or dividends while it is held. This lack of yield can be a drawback for investors looking for passive income streams from their investments.
  
  
• Performance Variability: Physical gold may not always outperform other investment classes like stocks or bonds, especially over long periods. For instance, the past decade has seen physical gold’s growth rate lag significantly behind major stock indices.
  
  
• Liquidity and Selling Challenges: Although gold is a universally recognized asset, its liquidity can vary. Selling physical gold can be cumbersome and might not fetch instant cash, especially in larger quantities. Additionally, finding a buyer often involves negotiation, which can further delay the process and potentially reduce the selling price.
  
  

Comparison Between Physical Gold and Gold ETFs

Tangibility and Usage

• Physical Gold: Investors hold physical gold directly, enabling them to use it as a medium of exchange in certain situations. This tangible asset offers direct ownership, which can be particularly appealing during times of economic instability.
  
  
• Gold ETFs: These represent an abstract form of investment as investors own shares in a fund rather than physical gold. This abstraction means gold ETFs cannot be used as a medium of exchange.
  

Storage and Insurance

• Physical Gold: Requires secure storage solutions and insurance to protect against theft or loss. These needs introduce additional costs but provide less exposure to market fluctuations, preserving the value of the investment during economic downturns.
  
  
• Gold ETFs: Investors do not need to worry about physical storage or insurance, which reduces costs. However, they are subject to stock market volatility which can affect the investment value quickly.
  

Investment Liquidity and Conversion

• Physical Gold: While offering a stable investment, converting physical gold into cash or other assets can be cumbersome and time-consuming, potentially involving negotiation and physical transportation.
  
  
• Gold ETFs: Provide high liquidity as they can be bought and sold like stocks on an exchange. Converting these into physical gold is not practical; investors usually sell their ETF shares and use the proceeds to purchase physical gold if desired.
  
  

How To Invest in Gold ETFs

Investing in Gold ETFs involves a straightforward process that can be broken down into several key steps, ensuring accessibility and ease for investors:

1. Choosing a Platform:
   
   
   • To start investing in Gold ETFs, one must first select an online brokerage or trading platform. Popular options include Fidelity, Vanguard, Public, and Robinhood. These platforms offer various Gold ETFs, such as SPDR Gold Shares (GLD) and iShares Gold Trust (IAU).
     
     
2. Account Setup:
   
   
   • Open a brokerage account through your chosen platform. This process typically involves providing personal information, setting up funding options, and completing a verification process.
     
     
3. Research and Selection:
   
   
   • Conduct thorough research on different Gold ETFs to understand their performance history, expense ratios, and assets under management. Notable ETFs include VanEck Vectors Gold Miners ETF (GDX) and VanEck Vectors Junior Gold Miners (GDXJ).
     
     
   • Consider factors like the five-year returns and expense ratios of these ETFs. Also, assess whether the ETF is physically backed by gold or if it holds other gold-related assets.
     
     
4. Investment Process:
   
   
   • Once you have selected a Gold ETF, you can purchase shares directly through the online brokerage platform. Many brokerages offer the option to trade ETFs commission-free, which can reduce transaction costs.
     
     
   • Monitor your investment through the platform’s tools and adjust your portfolio as needed based on performance and financial goals.
     
     
5. Additional Features:
   
   
   • Some platforms like Kinesis not only allow trading in traditional Gold ETFs but also offer digital currencies backed by physical gold, such as Kinesis gold (KAU). This can provide a more direct link to physical gold assets.
     
     
   • Kinesis also integrates features like a virtual card, which enables spending gold and silver at millions of locations worldwide, with instant fiat conversion. This can add a practical spending utility to your gold investments.
     
     

Best Ways To Buy Physical Gold

When considering the best ways to purchase physical gold, potential investors have several options, each with specific benefits and considerations. Here’s a detailed guide to help you navigate the process:

Sources for Buying Physical Gold

• Government and Private Mints: These institutions offer gold bullion, coins, and sometimes collectible items directly to the public.
  
  
• Precious Metals Dealers and Jewelers: Local and online dealers, such as JM Bullion, American Precious Metals Exchange (APMEX), and American Hartford Gold, provide a wide range of gold products.
  
  Local dealers allow the advantage of inspecting the gold in person and direct interaction with knowledgeable staff.
  
  
• Banks: Some banks in the U.S. sell gold bars and coins, adding a layer of trust and convenience for their customers.
  
  

Key Considerations When Purchasing

• Purity and Weight: Always check the purity, typically listed in karats or fineness, and the weight of the gold, usually in ounces or grams. These factors directly affect the value of the gold.
  
  
• Authenticity and Premiums: Verify the authenticity of the gold and be aware of the premium over the spot price of gold. Premiums cover the costs of fabrication, distribution, and a small dealer markup.
  
  
• Testing for Authenticity: Perform simple tests such as the magnet test (gold is non-magnetic), the ping test (genuine gold has a distinct sound), or the float test to help ensure the gold is not counterfeit.
  
  

Comparing Prices and Avoiding Scams

• Price Comparison: Always compare the prices offered by multiple sellers with the current spot price of gold to ensure you are getting a fair deal.
  
  
• Buying Gold Jewelry: If opting for gold jewelry, remember that the gold content will be just a percentage of its overall weight, expressed in karats, and consider the craftsmanship value.
  
  

Who Should Choose Physical Gold and Who Should Go for Gold ETFs

Choosing between physical gold and gold ETFs depends largely on the investor’s objectives, risk tolerance, and preferences for liquidity and direct ownership. Here’s a detailed breakdown to guide individual investors on which investment might suit them best:

Investors Who Should Choose Physical Gold

1. Direct Ownership Enthusiasts: Those who prefer having tangible assets can opt for physical gold. This includes investors who value the ability to hold, see, and manage their investment directly without intermediaries.
   
   
2. Long-term Investors: Individuals looking for long-term wealth preservation might find physical gold appealing due to its historical stability and potential to appreciate over time. It’s also suitable for those considering inheritance and heirlooms.
   
   
3. High Risk Tolerance for Liquidity Issues: If an investor is not concerned about immediate liquidity or selling their assets quickly, physical gold can be a viable option. This is particularly relevant for those who can manage the potential delays and negotiations involved in liquidating large quantities of gold.
   
   

Investors Who Should Go for Gold ETFs

1. Cost-Conscious Investors: Those looking for a more cost-effective way to invest in gold, without the burdens of storage, insurance, and high initial outlays, might prefer gold ETFs. This option eliminates the need for physical security and reduces overhead costs associated with physical gold.
   
   
2. Investors Seeking Liquidity: Gold ETFs offer high liquidity, allowing investors to buy and sell shares quickly and efficiently, much like trading stocks. This is ideal for investors who value flexibility and the ability to react swiftly to market changes.
   
   
3. Diversification Seekers: Investors aiming to diversify their portfolios without the direct risks of physical gold storage might find gold ETFs attractive. These funds can offer exposure to various gold-related assets, including gold mining stocks and gold futures contracts, providing a broader market reach.

Each investment type serves different needs and comes with its own set of advantages and considerations. Investors should assess their individual financial goals, risk tolerance, and investment strategy to make the most informed decision between physical gold and gold ETFs.

FAQs