Best Super Tuscan Wines To Invest In 2025 (Prices & ROI)

In 2025, the fine wine investment market continues to favor rare and age-worthy assets—and few categories have performed as consistently well as some of the best Super Tuscan wines. Emerging in the 1970s as rebellious expressions against Italy’s restrictive DOC regulations, Super Tuscans like Sassicaia, Tignanello, and Masseto have since evolved into globally sought-after investment-grade wines with exceptional financial performance.

Unlike standard Chianti or Brunello, Super Tuscans use non-native grape varietals such as Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, and Syrah, often blended with Sangiovese. This freedom in viticulture, combined with meticulous production and limited allocations, results in wines that rival—and often outperform—top Bordeaux and Napa labels in both quality and return on investment (ROI).

From a portfolio diversification perspective, Super Tuscans offer several advantages:

• Low volatility relative to equities or crypto assets
• Physical asset-backed value, offering intrinsic scarcity
• Strong secondary market liquidity via auction houses and private collectors

Furthermore, growing global demand—especially from Asian and North American collectors—has compressed supply margins, pushing secondary market prices up.

For instance, the average price of top Super Tuscans has increased by over 40% in the past five years, according to industry indexes, cementing their role as stable and high-performing investment vehicles.

Historical ROI & Market Performance of Super Tuscan Wines

While Burgundy and Bordeaux have traditionally dominated fine wine investment, Super Tuscans have carved a robust niche in global portfolios, delivering consistently strong returns with relatively low volatility. These wines—produced outside of Italy’s traditional DOCG classifications—have become elite assets in their own right, often surpassing their French counterparts in both critical acclaim and investment-grade performance.

Historical ROI of Super Tuscan Wines

Over the last 20 years, top-tier Super Tuscans have produced annualized returns between 10–16%, with flagship labels like Sassicaia, Tignanello, and Masseto outperforming the Liv-ex Italy 100 index on multiple occasions. According to historical auction data and private sales, well-stored back vintages of Sassicaia and Masseto have appreciated by more than 200% over the past decade.

For example:

• Sassicaia 2016, released at around $230 per bottle, currently trades at $480+, representing a 108% ROI in under 9 years.
  
  
• Masseto 2006 was priced at $280 upon release but reached $1,000+ by 2024, delivering a 257% ROI for early investors.
  
  
• Tignanello 2010, once obtainable for $90–100, now commands $280–300 in pristine condition—a 3x price increase in just over a decade.

These figures are not outliers. The Liv-ex Italy 100—which tracks the price performance of the most traded Italian fine wines, most of which are Super Tuscans—has risen steadily, climbing 14.1% in 2021 alone, and maintaining positive momentum into 2024 despite economic headwinds.

Why Super Tuscans Perform Well as Investments

Super Tuscans benefit from three key value-driving factors:

1. Limited Production Volumes: Many of the top wines are produced in extremely small quantities, often between 20,000 to 30,000 bottles per vintage (e.g., Masseto), with even more limited release formats like magnums or double magnums being highly collectible.

2. Global Collector Demand: Demand for Super Tuscans spans both mature and emerging markets. Asian collectors—especially in Hong Kong and Singapore—have increased their allocations of Sassicaia and Ornellaia by over 30% since 2019, driving up prices on the secondary market.

3. High Critical Scores & Longevity: With multiple 98–100 point ratings from Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate and James Suckling, Super Tuscans combine aging potential (20–30 years) with critical prestige. These attributes make them ideal for long-term holds.

Super Tuscans vs. Other Fine Wines

Compared to Burgundy, Super Tuscans offer similar upside with lower price volatility and greater accessibility, particularly for newer investors.

Market Outlook for 2025 and Beyond

Forecasts for 2025 remain bullish. Wine analysts project that the top 10 Super Tuscans will appreciate by 8–12% annually through 2027, barring macroeconomic shocks. What’s more, rising scarcity—particularly for older vintages—is expected to accelerate secondary market activity.

Key investment trends shaping the market include:

• Growing demand for provenance-tracked bottles, driven by blockchain-based wine storage platforms.
  
  
• Increased institutional interest, with wine funds allocating larger portions to Italy due to Bordeaux fatigue.
  
  
• Premiumization of Tuscan terroir, with Bolgheri wines commanding record-breaking prices.

Auction houses like Sotheby’s and Zachys have also reported increased bidding activity for verticals of Sassicaia and Ornellaia, with hammer prices exceeding high estimates by up to 40% in late 2024.

Masseto by Tenuta dell’Ornellaia

Masseto is widely considered one of the most prestigious and investable Super Tuscan wines in the world. Produced in Bolgheri by Tenuta dell’Ornellaia, this 100% Merlot wine has developed a cult following among collectors and institutional wine investors due to its limited production, critical acclaim, and consistent price appreciation across vintages.

Terroir & Winemaking

Located on the Tuscan coast, the Masseto vineyard sits on a unique terroir dominated by compact blue clay and marine sediments, a rare soil profile that retains moisture and contributes to the wine’s dense structure and long aging potential. The vineyard spans approximately 6.6 hectares, and each micro-plot is harvested and vinified separately, allowing for precision winemaking.

Yields are kept intentionally low to maximize concentration. Masseto is aged for 24 months in French oak barriques, followed by 12 months of bottle aging before release.

Annual production rarely exceeds 30,000 bottles, making it one of the most exclusive Italian wines on the market.

Investment Performance

From an investment perspective, Masseto offers some of the highest historical ROIs among Italian wines:

• Masseto 2010: Released at approximately $400, it now trades above $1,150, representing a 187% ROI over 13 years.
  
  
• Masseto 2016: Scored 100 points from James Suckling. Prices climbed from $700 at release to over $1,200 in less than five years.
  
  
• Masseto 2006 (Magnum): Sold at Sotheby’s for $4,500 in 2023, up from a retail price of $1,800 just a few years earlier.

Across vintages, the average annualized return on Masseto over a 10-year horizon stands between 11% and 15%, depending on provenance and format. Additionally, its inclusion in the Liv-ex Italy 100 Index further reinforces its position as a benchmark investment wine in the Italian fine wine category.

Market Outlook for 2025

The market for Masseto in 2025 remains bullish. Key drivers include:

• Global scarcity of aged back vintages
• Growing demand from Asian investors, particularly in Hong Kong and Singapore
• Institutional allocations from fine wine funds and wealth managers

Moreover, the newly opened state-of-the-art Masseto winery and caveau (cellar vault) has elevated the brand’s prestige, enhancing both its narrative and value on the secondary market.

In summary, Masseto combines limited availability, critical acclaim, and a proven ROI track record—making it one of the best Super Tuscan wines to invest in for 2025.

Case Basse di Gianfranco Soldera Toscana IGT – Brunello di Montalcino DOCG

Case Basse di Gianfranco Soldera is one of the most exclusive names in Italian winemaking and one of the best Super Tuscan wines to invest, known for producing ultra-premium Sangiovese wines that command high prices and deliver consistent returns for investors. Located in the heart of Montalcino, this estate does not follow commercial production norms.

Instead, it focuses on ultra-limited releases of wines that regularly appear in high-end auctions and private cellars.

Terroir & Production

The estate lies on a 23-hectare property in southern Montalcino, of which only a small portion—around 8 hectares—is planted to vine. The vineyards are set at elevations around 320 meters, offering an ideal combination of sunlight exposure, altitude, and ventilation. The soils are a complex mix of marl, clay, and limestone, giving Soldera wines their unmistakable structure and minerality.

Everything about the winemaking process is minimal intervention. Fermentation occurs with native yeasts in large Slavonian oak casks. Aging lasts up to 6 years before bottling, and each vintage reflects a strong emphasis on purity, balance, and age-worthiness.

Annual production is extremely small, usually capped between 6,000 and 15,000 bottles, depending on vintage conditions.

Investment Performance

Soldera wines consistently outperform market averages for Italian fine wines. Historical auction and private market data support this:

• Soldera Brunello di Montalcino Riserva 2006: Initially priced around €200, this wine trades today for €850–€950, reflecting a 325% total return, or an annualized ROI of 16–18% over 12 years.
  
  
• Soldera Toscana IGT 2015: Released at €410, bottles with original provenance now fetch over €650, indicating strong short-term price growth in under 5 years.
  
  
• Rare formats (Magnums, double Magnums) have reached up to €2,500–€3,000 at Sotheby’s and Zachys auctions in the last 24 months.

What makes Soldera particularly compelling is the combination of critical prestige, severe scarcity, and no compromise production philosophy.

Unlike larger estates, Case Basse often declassifies entire vintages or destroys wine that doesn’t meet quality standards, making every released bottle inherently valuable.

2025 Market Outlook

Investor interest in Soldera is expected to remain strong in 2025. Key drivers include:

• Rising demand from Asia and the U.S., where fine wine collecting continues to grow among HNWIs
  
  
• Increasing scarcity of back vintages, especially post-2017, after a cellar sabotage reduced production
  
  
• Strong resale performance at global auctions, with newer vintages quickly reaching maturity in the investment cycle

Soldera’s cult status, along with its absence from mass retail and limited global distribution, gives it a unique positioning in the fine wine market. The brand is trusted for quality and integrity—two characteristics that drive long-term capital appreciation.

For investors seeking high-performing, ultra-rare Super Tuscan wines with proven price appreciation and global prestige, Case Basse di Gianfranco Soldera remains a top-tier asset in 2025.

Tenuta San Guido – Sassicaia Bolgheri D.O.C. 2017

The 2017 vintage of Sassicaia by Tenuta San Guido is a standout Super Tuscan wine with proven investment appeal. Despite being a challenging growing year due to extreme summer heat and lower-than-average yields, Sassicaia 2017 emerged as one of the most critically praised and financially rewarding vintages of the past decade.

Terroir & Winemaking

The Sassicaia estate lies in the Bolgheri region on Tuscany’s coastal Maremma, where maritime breezes and gravel-rich soils create ideal conditions for Bordeaux varietals. The 2017 vintage blends 85% Cabernet Sauvignon and 15% Cabernet Franc, carefully harvested early to avoid overripeness during the intense heat of the growing season.

Aging took place over 24 months in French oak barrels, followed by additional bottle aging to enhance integration and longevity.

The result is a structured, refined wine with excellent cellar potential—estimated to peak between 2027 and 2040.

Investment Performance

Sassicaia 2017 has delivered solid gains since its release, appealing to both private collectors and institutional investors:

• Release Price (2019): ~€135 per bottle
  
  
• 2025 Market Price: Trades for €290–€310, reflecting a 115% increase in just five years
  
  
• Case Price Growth: A 6-bottle case released at ~€810 now retails for over €1,850

It also received strong critical endorsements:

• 96 points – James Suckling
• 94 points – Wine Spectator
• 93+ points – Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate

Sassicaia 2017 was also featured in Liv-ex’s most traded wines by value in 2021 and 2022, reinforcing its relevance in global investment portfolios.

Market Outlook for 2025

The 2017 Sassicaia remains undervalued relative to other top vintages like 2015 and 2016, making it an appealing buy for investors seeking mid-term upside potential. Its shorter initial yield—estimated at 25% lower than average—has added scarcity to the market.

Key investment drivers:

• High critic scores and early maturity make it accessible to a broader range of buyers.
  
  
• Low global availability as secondary stock tightens.
  
  
• Proven brand reputation, with Sassicaia maintaining its status as one of Italy’s most bankable fine wines.

For investors looking for a premium Super Tuscan with a strong five-year track record and upside still to unlock, Sassicaia 2017 offers excellent risk-adjusted returns.

Biondi Santi’s Brunello di Montalcino Riserva

Biondi Santi’s Brunello di Montalcino Riserva is one of Italy’s most iconic fine wines and a benchmark for age-worthy Sangiovese. Known for its limited production, strict vintage selection, and extraordinary aging potential, this wine remains a cornerstone of long-term wine investment strategies.

Terroir & Production

The estate, Tenuta Greppo, is located in southern Tuscany at elevations between 300 and 500 meters. The vineyards benefit from a cool, continental climate with excellent diurnal temperature variation, which preserves acidity and enhances aromatic precision in the grapes.

The Riserva is produced only in exceptional vintages and sourced exclusively from vines that are over 25 years old, many of which are planted with the historic BBS11 clone of Sangiovese Grosso—selected and propagated by the Biondi Santi family themselves.

Fermentation takes place in traditional Slavonian oak vats, and the wine undergoes 36 to 48 months of aging in large neutral oak casks, followed by extended bottle aging before release.

This minimal intervention approach results in wines of remarkable purity and structure, capable of evolving for 30–50 years in optimal cellaring conditions.

Investment Performance

Biondi Santi Riserva has consistently demonstrated strong returns in both private and public wine markets:

• 1955 Riserva: Widely regarded as one of Italy’s greatest wines, this vintage has sold for €3,000–€5,000 per bottle at international auctions.
  
  
• 2012 Riserva: Scored 100 points from The Wine Independent and has risen from an initial release price of ~€480 to €850+ in just a few years.
  
  
• Average Vintage ROI: Between 10–12% annually for well-stored bottles from investment-grade vintages.

Collectors prize this wine for its scarcity and reputation. Production volumes rarely exceed 10,000 bottles, and older vintages are extremely limited on the secondary market, which continues to drive premium pricing.

Market Outlook for 2025

The outlook for Biondi Santi’s Brunello Riserva remains highly favorable heading into 2025. Demand for age-worthy Italian wines has accelerated globally, particularly in Asia and North America, where collectors are turning to iconic producers outside of Bordeaux and Burgundy for portfolio diversification.

Key factors supporting future price appreciation:

• Scarcity of older vintages combined with strong vertical collector demand
  
  
• Limited release schedule, as Riserva is not produced annually
  
  
• Continued global recognition from top critics and auction houses

For serious investors in fine wine, Biondi Santi’s Brunello di Montalcino Riserva delivers the ideal blend of heritage, scarcity, and proven ROI. It remains one of the best Super Tuscan-style wines to hold long-term in a high-performing wine portfolio.

Case Basse di Gianfranco Soldera Brunello di Montalcino Riserva DOCG

The Brunello di Montalcino Riserva DOCG from Case Basse di Gianfranco Soldera is one of the most revered expressions of Sangiovese in the global fine wine market. Known for its uncompromising quality standards, extreme scarcity, and long-term aging potential, this wine continues to deliver exceptional returns for high-net-worth collectors and wine investors.

Terroir & Production

Located in the southern reaches of Montalcino, the Case Basse estate spans 23 hectares, with only a fraction dedicated to vines. Vines are planted at 320–350 meters elevation, where they benefit from steady breezes, cool nights, and a diverse mix of limestone and clay soils.

Soldera’s winemaking philosophy is rooted in natural viticulture and minimal intervention. Indigenous yeast fermentation takes place in large neutral oak vats, followed by extended aging—often 5 to 6 years in Slavonian oak casks.

Production volumes are extremely limited, typically fewer than 10,000 bottles per vintage, and entire vintages are occasionally declassified or discarded if they do not meet strict quality standards.

This obsessive attention to quality has made the Riserva DOCG a true benchmark for purity and complexity in Brunello.

Investment Performance

Soldera’s Brunello Riserva wines have become highly prized on the secondary market, consistently delivering above-average returns:

• 1990 Vintage: A 6-bottle lot sold for $12,500 at Christie’s in 2022, well above initial estimates.
  
  
• 1999 Vintage: A 12-bottle case reached $15,535 in 2020, showing continued value appreciation for mature stock.
  
  
• 2014 Vintage: Saw a 50.4% increase in market price in 2022 alone, as tracked by Liv-ex.

These prices reflect the wine’s scarcity, consistent critical acclaim, and established legacy. ROI for select vintages has ranged from 12% to 18% annually, especially for wines with original wooden cases (OWC) and perfect provenance.

Market Outlook for 2025

As we look ahead, the investment thesis for Soldera’s Brunello di Montalcino Riserva remains strong:

• Supply-side constraints due to small-batch production
• Increasing global demand from both collectors and institutional buyers
• Elevated auction activity for verticals and rare formats

Furthermore, wines from this estate are rarely discounted or traded on open retail platforms, which helps preserve their price integrity on the secondary market.

In short, for investors seeking a blue-chip Super Tuscan with long-term growth potential, historical price resilience, and unrivaled brand prestige, Case Basse di Gianfranco Soldera Brunello di Montalcino Riserva DOCG stands among the top-tier assets for 2025.

Tignanello Toscana IGT 2010 BALT

Tignanello 2010 is one of the most iconic modern vintages from Marchesi Antinori’s Super Tuscan flagship. Blending traditional Sangiovese with international varietals, this vintage has earned a permanent place in fine wine investment portfolios due to its impressive track record of value growth and strong critic endorsements.

Terroir & Production

The Tignanello estate is located in the heart of Chianti Classico, in the hills between the Greve and Pesa river valleys. Its limestone-rich, well-drained soils and southwest-facing slopes provide an ideal terroir for ripening Sangiovese alongside Cabernet Sauvignon and Cabernet Franc.

The 2010 growing season offered near-perfect conditions—cool early temperatures followed by a long, dry summer—resulting in small, concentrated berries. The final blend consists of 80% Sangiovese, 15% Cabernet Sauvignon, and 5% Cabernet Franc.

The wine was aged for 12–14 months in French and Hungarian oak, then matured in bottle for another year before release.

Investment Performance

Tignanello 2010 has delivered a solid performance in the fine wine market and continues to show strong liquidity:

• Original Release Price: ~€70 per bottle upon release in 2013
  
  
• Current Market Price (2025): Trades between €180 and €220, depending on condition and provenance
  
  
• 12-Year ROI: Over 160% growth, with an annualized return of 8–9%

Notable accolades:

• 96 points – Robert Parker’s Wine Advocate
• 97 points – James Suckling
• Considered one of the finest Tignanello vintages ever released

Tignanello’s broad appeal—spanning collectors, drinkers, and institutional investors—has helped maintain stable demand and secondary market visibility, particularly for older benchmark vintages like 2010.

Market Outlook for 2025

Tignanello 2010 is expected to continue appreciating steadily as back-vintage availability declines and collector interest intensifies. The wine is now entering its prime drinking window, enhancing desirability across private clients, retailers, and restaurants.

Key drivers of value:

• Mature vintage scarcity with increasing global consumption
• Strong brand identity as one of the first and most successful Super Tuscans
• High score pedigree ensures ongoing market relevance

For fine wine investors seeking a highly rated, well-aged Super Tuscan with consistent upward pricing trends and strong brand backing, Tignanello 2010 is a reliable and strategic asset to include in a 2025 portfolio.

FAQ